Talmud & The Casuistic Style (Shlomo Deshen & the Jews of Morocco)


Working through 18th and 19th century halakhic sources (in this case, responsa) to get a bead on traditional Moroccan Jewish life prior to formal colonial period (prior to the establishment of the French protectorate in 1912), Shlomo Deshen said something interesting in this classic study about the Talmud and the casuistic style.

In a comment that should bedevil the work of any social historian who relies on this material, Deshen writes:

“The reasoning of Talmudic sage, as they advance towards conclusions, frequently leads them to describe scenarios that could theoretically have arisen in the case discussed. The sages describe ways of action that protagonists could have chosen and other eventualities that could have arisen. Sometimes these scenarios are based on elements of real-life possibilities, but more often they are the products of legal minds that are steeped in Talmudic literature and precedents of other times and places. Insensitive reading of the responsa material sometimes leads researchers to impute reality to casuistic statements that are completely imaginary” (The Mellah Society: Jewish Community Life in Sherifian Morocco, p.12).

The same sensitivity should be required also of Jewish philosophers when they write about law and authority, and also about scholars of rabbinics who perform symptomatic readings of the texts in order to get a grip on social history and social tensions. Key words in Deshen’s statement include “theoretical,” “could have,” “scenarios,” “products,” “literature,” impute” and “completely imaginary,” and also””frequently” and “sometimes.”



About zjb

Zachary Braiterman is Professor of Religion in the Department of Religion at Syracuse University. His specialization is modern Jewish thought and philosophical aesthetics. http://religion.syr.edu
This entry was posted in uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Talmud & The Casuistic Style (Shlomo Deshen & the Jews of Morocco)

  1. dmf says:

    semiotics can be very slippery…
    After the call went out on 4chan, a network of new Twitter accounts run by white supremacists pretending to be Jews popped up. Often, they masquerade as Orthodox Jews, Israelis and/or Jewish leftists. They all follow each other and promote anti-Semitic and anti-Israel content.

  2. dmf says:

    either, or…
    Here’s the video of Trump saying, “I think any Jewish people that vote for a Democrat, I think it shows either a total lack of knowledge or great disloyalty.”
    Via CSPAN

  3. dmf says:

    for the more literally minded
    “Thank you to Wayne Allyn Root for the very nice words. “President Trump is the greatest President for Jews and for Israel in the history of the world, not just America, he is the best President for Israel in the history of the world…and the Jewish people in Israel love him….
    like he’s the King of Israel. They love him like he is the second coming of God…But American Jews don’t know him or like him. They don’t even know what they’re doing or saying anymore. It makes no sense! But that’s OK, if he keeps doing what he’s doing, he’s good for…..”

Leave a Reply